Local SEO Tips and Tricks
We Turned Down a $2,500/Month SEO Client: Here’s Why (Local SEO Tier List)
Is SEO worth it for every small business? No. We turned down an interior design client because we couldn’t justify the return. In this local SEO tier list I rank 17 industries from S to F, from plumbers, HVAC and lawyers to dentists, realtors and restaurants, based on where their customers look first.
Watch on YouTube: We Turned Down a $2,500/Month SEO Client: Here's Why (Local SEO Tier List)
Why we turned down a $2,500/month SEO client
Last week, Carmen and I had to turn down a potential client who was willing to pay us $2,500 a month for interior design SEO. It might sound crazy. We’re still going to help them out in other ways, just not with SEO, because we couldn’t justify the ROI we would bring them.
It also gave me the idea for this video: rank 17 industries from S tier to F tier on whether or not they need SEO. We’re not going to advise anybody to take on SEO services if we don’t think it’s going to be profitable for them.
S tier, Essentials: plumbing and HVAC, lawyers (personal injury, criminal, family), garage door, movers and junk removal, roofing.
A tier, Big Ticket: electricians, remodelers and general contractors.
B tier, Ask a Friend First: dentists, chiropractors, cleaning.
C tier, Know Your Market: financial advisors (mortgage, insurance, realtors), painters, solar installers.
D tier, Zero Click Marketing: architects, interior designers, wedding photographers.
F tier, Don’t Need: restaurants.
F tier, Don’t Need: restaurants
I only put restaurants here to prove a point. Restaurants get huge search volume, about 253 million searches a month. The issue is that nobody needs a specific restaurant, other than maybe a super luxury one. If you’re hungry, there are usually 20 places within five minutes, depending on where you live.
Think about the customer journey. People go on Google Maps or Yelp, search “Italian restaurant near me,” and choose one of the top two or three results. Maybe they look at photos. If you’re a restaurant owner, all you really need is a nice website, some reviews and a Google Business Profile.
D tier, Zero Click Marketing: architects, interior designers, wedding photographers
These are a little different. Look at how many people search for each industry: architect, wedding photographer and interior designer take up three of the bottom four. People aren’t necessarily making these decisions on Google. They make some of them there, but it’s not going to justify the cost a lot of the time.
Nobody Googles “interior designer near me” and goes with the first option. It’s called zero click marketing for a reason. People find and trust these businesses through Instagram, Pinterest and YouTube, and that’s where the leads convert. Yes, you still need a nice website and proof.
For the interior designer I mentioned at the beginning, we’re going to help with Google Business Profile optimization and a website. Other than that, we’re really leaning into social media.
C tier, Know Your Market: realtors, mortgage, insurance, financial advisors
I labeled this one Know Your Market because it’s really important to understand where your business comes from and where people are searching for you. We put realtors, mortgage brokers, insurance brokers and financial advisors in this tier, because it depends on the search behavior where you are.
Say you live in a small town in Michigan with not a lot of turnover. Everybody refers each other. Not a lot of people leave, and not a lot of people move there. You really don’t want SEO in an industry like this, in a location like that.
If you’re in New York City, Philadelphia, Chicago or California, a lot of people move in and out, and you want to rely on search. People don’t have those networks built up, so you get less referral business and more people searching for you. It works the other way too: if you rely on a referral network and they all move away over the next decade or two, that network dries up. You need a constant flow of organic search, through SEO, through Google and through people asking ChatGPT.
This is one of my favorites, and it really depends on you. If you have questions about your market, reach out and I can walk you through it.
B tier, Ask a Friend First: dentists, chiropractors, cleaning
What do dentists, chiropractors and cleaning companies have in common? They’re trust-driven industries. If you’re looking for a dentist, you usually ask around, because if you’re a family, they’re going to be in your kid’s mouth. A chiropractor is going to work on your back, so you need to know they’re experienced and won’t mess you up. A cleaning company may be in your house alone, so you need to trust they won’t steal anything. A lot of these industries come through recommendations.
So why are they ranked so highly? Search volume. Dentists get about 3.9 million searches a month nationwide across their top local searches, like “dentist near me.” It’s huge. Dental offices use SEO a lot because they know people find them online. Yes, through referrals, but primarily online as well.
And these leads are sticky. I went to the same family dentist for the first 18 years of my life. Unless you do a really bad job, you’re not going to lose that customer. If you onboard a family, whatever you paid for that one lead is going to pay off for decades.
A tier, Big Ticket: electricians, remodelers and general contractors
These could be S tier. The reason they’re not is that nobody searches for them in a panic. S tier has a lot of panicked searchers. Nobody is looking for a remodeler at 2 a.m. on a Saturday.
These are big-ticket jobs, and people spend time researching them. You really have to show up in search, have a nice website, rank highly, and have evidence everywhere that you’re qualified, with good reviews. They won’t get the volume of a restaurant, but every deal is worth fighting for. A bathroom remodel could be $20,000. A kitchen remodel, $60,000.
Our remodeler clients are really fun to work with: showing their proof, getting them found in search, and earning those big-ticket jobs. Some of our favorite texts are remodeler clients telling us about a huge job they just landed.
S tier, Essentials: plumbing and HVAC, lawyers, garage door, movers and junk removal, roofing
In my opinion, these businesses won’t survive and thrive for decades unless they invest in SEO and marketing. We have a ton of clients who come to us after 30 years in plumbing, HVAC or another trade, and quite frankly, their lead sources are drying up. Their phones aren’t ringing as much as they used to, because people find this information online. They know SEO works. It’s a must-have, and these are the companies we work with the most because they get the highest return on investment.
Think about it. If you have water damage at 3 o’clock on a Saturday, you need a plumber who can come over and assess the problem. Lawyers: if you get picked up and put in jail, get a DUI or get into a car accident, these are sensitive situations. People don’t necessarily share their trials and tribulations with their network, so referrals are harder to come by, and people go by reputation online. Movers and junk removal: people just want a mover with good reviews, because they don’t want the stress. Roofers, same thing.
The numbers back it up, and it’s not only about search volume. These are high-ticket jobs. Look at what one Google Ads click costs. That’s the cost per click, not the cost per lead. Personal injury attorneys, one of the biggest industries in SEO, pay upwards of $200 per click. If 10% of those clicks become leads, they’re paying over $2,000 a lead. That sounds insane, but it isn’t when their margins are massive and each case is huge.
These industries thrive on SEO, and with everybody searching more and more online, it’s arguably required. That’s why they’ve earned S tier.
Before you spend a dollar on SEO
If you take one thing from this video: before you spend a dollar on SEO, investigate where your leads come from. Not just for you, but for your industry, your niche and where you are. If a lot of those leads come from online search, I’d argue SEO is pretty much mandatory.
We do audits on our YouTube channel, and we also do private ones. If you want us to look at your company in its totality, we won’t just tell you what’s technically wrong with your SEO.